How to make sheet cake from a layer cake recipe (2024)

At King Arthur Flour, we believe that one of the best parts of baking is sharing with others. Whether you try a new recipe with a friend or you bring a neighbor ahomemade treat, baking is most rewarding when shared. But with so many suitable recipes to choose from, how do you pick what to make?

We've got you covered —bake cake, of course! You’re guaranteed to make someone’s day if you bake them cake.And don't bake just any cake. Bake a sheet cake.

Sheet cake: it's quick to frost, easy to decorate, travels well, and can feed a crowd.

There are a number of single-layer cake recipes on our website (54 to be exact), but don't confine yourself to these recipes. We'll show you how to bake a layer cake recipe in a 9" x13" pan so you're always ready to bake and share sheet cake.

How to make sheet cake from a layer cake recipe (1)

If you want to convert acake recipe but don't have a 9" x13" pan, check out our blog, The essential alternative baking pan sizes, for more options.

Which recipes can be turned into a sheet cake?

When choosing a recipe to convert to a 9" x 13"sheet cake, thereare a few things to keep in mind. For best results, choose a cake recipe that calls for baking the batter in two orthree 8” round pans, or two 9” round pans.

You're looking forrecipes that make about 6 cups of batter — this amount fits perfectly into a 9” x13” pan.

Keep in mind, not all cake recipescan be seamlesslyconverted to a sheet cake. Skip recipes that don’t use a mixing method ofcreaming, blending, or the paste method. Anything that's not a standard caketends to misbehave in a sheet pan. For example, sponge cakes (like Angel Food Cake) or cakes with a meringue layer arebest left in the original format the recipe calls for.

How to make sheet cake from a layer cake recipe (2)

What better recipe to show you how to make sheet cake than our 2019 Recipe of the Year, Classic Birthday Cake? It's a showstopping centerpiece for special celebrations in its original layer cake form, but it works beautifully as a sheet cake, too.

Whether you have your own favorite layer cake recipe or you’re ready to use our Classic Birthday Cake, we’ll teach you everything you need to know to transform a layer cakeinto a sheet cake, a format that’s ideal for sharing.

Prepare your pan

Once you've chosen your recipe, it's time to start baking.

First step: make sure your pan is ready for the batter.Lightly grease a9” x13” pan with non-stick spray.You might also consider using a parchment paper sling to lineyour pan if you’d like to easily remove the cake before serving.

After you've prepared the pan,preheat the oven to 325°F (or the temperature called for in your recipe), and gather your ingredients.

Mix up the batter

Prepare the batter as described in your recipe. You don’t need to make any changes, even though you're converting the recipe from a layer cake to a sheet cake.

How to make sheet cake from a layer cake recipe (3)

Once the batter is smooth and ready to be baked, pour it into the prepared cake pan.

How long do youbake a sheet cake?

Here are some guidelines for how long to bake your sheet cake when starting with alayer cake recipe:

  • Two 8” rounds to a 9” x13” pan: Increase the bake time by 20% to 25%
  • Three 8” rounds to a 9” x13” pan: Increase the bake time by 25% to 30%
  • Two 9” rounds to a 9” x13” pan: Increase the bake time by 30% to 40%

This will give you an idea of when you should start checking your cake for doneness.For example, if your recipe calls for baking in two 8" rounds for 38 to 42 minutes, multiply the low end of the range by 1.2 and the high end of the range by 1.25. This means the sheet cake version should take about 45 to 52 minutes to bake.

Remember to check your cake early and often, as these general rules simply help estimate the bake time. Some cakes might need more or less timeto bake as a sheet cake, depending on the recipe.

How to make sheet cake from a layer cake recipe (4)

The key to making sure your cake is perfectly baked is to use your senses. The center of the cakeshould feel springy to the touch. A paring knife or toothpick insertedinto the center of the cakeshould come out mostly clean. Best of all, your kitchen should smell heavenly when the cake is done baking.

For the Classic Birthday Cake made in a 9” x 13” pan, bake it for 45 to 48 minutes at 325°F until it tests done.

How much filling and frosting do I use?

If your recipe calls forfilling (rather than frosting) between the top and bottom layers, you’ll probably want to skip it. Sheet cakes aren’t easy to split and fill. You’re welcome to try if you’re feeling adventurous, though; ifthe original recipe calls for a single layer of filling, you’ll want to make a double batch for your sheet cake in order to ensure there’s enough to cover the entire surface.

As far as frosting goes, we find 3 cups is about right to frost a 9" x13" cake,plus some extra for piping and decorating. 2 cups will suffice if you’re OK with a thin layer of frosting; 4 cups will give you some excess.

In general, frosting recipes formulated for 8” or 9” layer cakes will make more than the necessary 3 cups of frosting. You’re welcome to make a full batch and simply freeze any extra; most frostings freeze quite well.

Alternately, you can downsize the frosting recipe. Try scaling down the frostingto 3/4 of a batch for your9” x 13” sheet cake. For you lovers of American-style buttercream, start with about 12 tablespoons of butter (or shortening) to end up with the right amount of frosting.

How to make sheet cake from a layer cake recipe (5)

Assemble your sheet cake

Once the cake is fully cooled, apply the frosting using the tool of your choice. (I can’t imagine using anything but a small offset spatula for this task.)

If you’re looking for decorating inspiration, check out our cake styling guide. The cakes shown are all layer cakes, but many of the techniques —swoops, waves, scallops, and sprinkles —can add personality to sheet cakes too.

My go-to decoration includes edible flowers, berries, and natural sprinkles. Let your imagination be your guide.

How to make sheet cake from a layer cake recipe (6)

Bake and share

Now that you know how to bake a perfect sheet cake, you can bake and share with someone in your life. We’re excited to let you know who wehave been baking for recently.

We’ve partnered with the Upper Valley Havenin White River Junction, Vermont,a non-profit organization that serves people struggling with poverty. The Haven provides food, shelter, education,and other support to those in need in our community.

How to make sheet cake from a layer cake recipe (7)

As bakers, we want to share the joy that comes from having something sweet to celebrate a special day. What day is more special in the life of a child than a birthday?!

We thought we'd put ourClassic Birthday Cakerecipe to good use and bakebirthday cakes for children at the Haven as a fun way to spread happiness.

How to make sheet cake from a layer cake recipe (8)

Birthday cakes for the Haven

As employee-owners, we’re each allotted 40 hours of paid volunteer time per year, with 10 of those hours dedicated to volunteering for organizations focusedon hunger relief. By baking for the Haven, we can use our volunteer time tobring some happiness to children in our community.

The sheet cake version of our Classic Birthday Cake is the perfect canvas to decorate in celebration ofbirthdays at the Haven. Here are some snapshots of the birthday cake baking we've done throughout the year:

How to make sheet cake from a layer cake recipe (9)

Bakers who wanted to avoid using a piping bag but still add writing to thecakes came up with some outstanding solutions.

How to make sheet cake from a layer cake recipe (10)

Occasionally, there aren't any children with birthdays during a certain month. In these cases, our bakers makea seasonally-themed cakeand everyone enjoys aspecial treat just because they can!

How to make sheet cake from a layer cake recipe (11)

Whatever the format —sheet cake, cupcakes, or layer cake — the treats are certainly appreciated by all at the Haven. For some of the children, it's the first time they've ever had a birthday cake made for them. We're truly honored to provide the children with something that makes them feel celebrated.

How to make sheet cake from a layer cake recipe (12)

We encourage you to bake andsharewith someone in your community, so you too can experience the rewarding feeling that comes from baking for others. It's sweeter than chocolate-frosted birthday cake.

If you'd like some inspiration, be sure to check out all of the layer cake recipes we have on our recipe site. Happy baking!

Thanks to Jenn Bakos for taking most of these photos, to the King Arthur Flour employee-owners who submitted photos of cake baking, and to the Haven for sharing photos of the children enjoying birthday cake!

How to make sheet cake from a layer cake recipe (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Trent Wehner

Last Updated:

Views: 6587

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (56 voted)

Reviews: 87% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Trent Wehner

Birthday: 1993-03-14

Address: 872 Kevin Squares, New Codyville, AK 01785-0416

Phone: +18698800304764

Job: Senior Farming Developer

Hobby: Paintball, Calligraphy, Hunting, Flying disc, Lapidary, Rafting, Inline skating

Introduction: My name is Trent Wehner, I am a talented, brainy, zealous, light, funny, gleaming, attractive person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.